CONSCIENCE VS. CONSTITUENTS
A Statute to Check the Bona Fides of Politico Declarations of Conscience, as justification for voting counter to their Constituency; and to Require (no escape Mandatory) Financial and Fact-Source Disclosures to see their financial stake.
Vetting The Blankie Defense
With Illustrations Parts I and II herein
WHEREAS: Elected officials at the federal and state levels often declare a blanket
don't touch me justification for a vote or position, as a matter of "conscience" (herein, the Blankie Defense, or Hiding Behind the Mantra); and so justify disregarding majority views among their constituents; and
WHEREAS: Elected officials also receive, simultaneously, before or after such Blankie Defense is declared, substantial funds from lobby groups seeking to influence in their favor, or buy, the vote of the elected official; knowing that "conscience" cannot be touched, once declared, or so they hope; and
WHEREAS: Constituents in the proper exercise of voting rights must be able assess the bona fides of the Blankie Defense of conscience by their elected officials. Is the declaration
a) truly conscience; or
b) self-serving as in the nature of
- pragmatic pocketbookism; or
- outright, underhanded, overreaching opportunism; or
- re-election motivated party-switching manipulation ego greed; or
- misassessment of fact; in which case, if egregious and reasonably intended to mislead others, the official's bona fides are conclusively established as non.
THEREFORE:
1. Declaration, Transparency. Elected officials must declare their position 21 days prior to a vote on major legislation, or declare that The Mind Is Open; and update that declaration regularly.
2. Running Counter to Constituency. If such position runs counter to the majority constituent view in their jurisdiction (see process for such determination below) for reasons of conscience (that conscience mantra again) or other ground, the elected official shall be deemed to be, obviously, Running Counter, and shall be subject to these disclosure requirements so the conscience or other ground can be vetted:
a. Disclosure of financial or other benefits from individuals or entities interested in the outcome, and identify such.
- This benefits disclosure shall include what he or she has received or from which he or she has or can enjoy as to funds, perks, airtime, payments for his or her benefit, travel, by any lobby or industry individual or group with an interest in the outcome of the vote;
- The disclosure requirement shall extend for a time period not less than the past 7 years, such time period to satisfy many religious requirements; the alternative being 40 and that is too much; and shall also include any benefits or funds to be received during the next 7 years, if not already handily in pocket or otherwise enjoyed.
b. Disclosure of factual bases for fact-based positions.
- the supporting factual information on which he or she relies in drawing his or her conclusions,
- the source of the information including who paid for it,
3. Measure of majority view; trigger for debate.
The majority view of the constituency shall be measured objectively, by such neutral polling as produces unskewed results by the nature and techniques of the questioning itself. The polling for majority view, or for the fact-based debate, shall be triggered by a petition signed by no less than 10 constituents; this low threshhold designed to ensure that elected officials shall disclose voluntarily in advance of such petition, knowing it is coming anyway.
4. Forum; Roberts Rules of Order Debate; or other Debating Rules Used in the Usual Course of Debating.
The elected official Running Counter shall then engage in a debate with constituent representatives in a civilized forum as to the facts. Civilized shall be defined as following Roberts Rules of Order.
The forum shall be nationally televised, and the disclosure shall be nationally publicized and documented, as to any federal elected official, and statewide as to any state elected official. FN 1
................................................................
FN 1 The Legislative Anti-Shenanigans Committee would like to thank Joe, for providing the impetus for this important Vetting Bona Fides legislation. Joe? Where are you? Joe? We have an award for you. (looking in all parties' regardless caucus rooms, with giant powder puff bequeathed from Uncle Miltie)
Heard offstage, a procession drawing nearer, participants singing like Aida:
Ach, du Lieber Lieberman, Lieberman, Lieberman.
Ach du Lieber Lieberman, Nein leben bist du. *
Here? There? (looking in back alleys where deals are made) And Everywhere?
Joe, where are you? Say not so. Anything To Everybody? (at the tailor - one size can be made to fit anybody, just watch the snip and cut) What? The water fits any glass? Regardless? Joe? Is that right? Were you elected so Joe can look after Joe? Who is Joe? Will you - this is the big one -
debate your fact sources and conclusions, instead of re-churning yourself on airtime? Time to disclose, Joe. No free passes for mere mantras or repeating somebody's talking points.
A good Joe vets, discloses and discusses. Thank you, Joe. Joe?
Oh. There you are. Unh-hunh.
....................................................
*
Ach du lieber, Augustin is an Austrian folk song that originated during the Plague years 1768-69, acording to DisAustria at ://www.wargame.ch/wc/nwc/newsletter/19th_edition/Newsletter19/DisAustria.html/.
The story: Augustin, excessively in his cups, dropped on the spot, was picked up by the body wagon passing by, tossed among the corpses, and then awoke, to his surprise at his surroundings, and his carriers, at his resurrection. Thereafter, apparently, uses of wine and spirits to counter infection became even more popular. See The translation at that site: O, my dear friend Augustin, everything's gone.... Ours, a little different. How to counter infections, viral spreads. Still with us.
Ach, du lieber Lieberman, Lieberman.
Ach, du lieber Lieberman,
Alles ist hin.
The Public; Con-stit-u-ents;
Trod un-der foot a-gain.
Ach, du lieber Lieberman,
Alles ist hin.
See Everything's Gone, at ://sedulia.blogs.com/sedulias_translations/2005/05/ach_du_lieber_a.html/.
Perhaps sing, not groupishly like a campfire, but slow, sad, like a little dirge-like round, 'round the rotunda .... perhaps in a deep minor key, A Minor, for Ach, beginning on the dominant 5th, E1 -- Hmmmmmmm: E/ F- E-D-C/ A-A/ ; B-E-E/ C-A-A; a little higher? G/ A-flat -G-F-E-flat -C-C/ D-G-G/ E-flat C-C... something like that. Did we mess that up? Would each audience, each gallery, people in every hallway entryway escape hatch, everywhere, sing to Joe until the Town Hallers Cry Nuncle.
Perhaps just a low, slow hum, then, as a round from section to section. Barely audible....M-m/-m/m-m/ m m-m/m-m-m/m-m-m/ m-m/m-m .....
MOI? Suggest such a return salvo? This for that? Is that fair? Is that what adults do?
Pas!